Reuters AlertNet Lite - Aid to Afghanistan is in crisis, says ActionAid

Reuters AlertNet Full site

FROM THE FIELD

Aid to Afghanistan is in crisis, says ActionAid

19 Feb 2008 11:00:38 GMT
Source: ActionAid

Background

• Afghan turmoil

MORE >>

International donors are letting Afghanistan down. Whilst they have been calling for greater transparency and accountability in Afghanistan, they themselves have failed to adhere to these values.

In a major new report tracking aid to Afghanistan, ActionAid and Afghanistan’s Economic Literacy and Budget Analysis Group say that the international community is following an inconsistent and incoherent approach to development in the country.

Donors have failed to deliver money pledged for aid, distributing US$5bn less than promised between 2002 and 2006, despite finding the many hundreds of billions necessary for military operations. Even when aid comes through it is often late and most of it sidesteps the Afghan government and parliament. Consequently it has become extremely difficult for the government to budget and deliver services efficiently.

The report argues that this is a key threat to fighting poverty and delivering tangible improvements to people’s lives, and one which ultimately could undermine the delivery of stable democracy.

The report shows that:

Aid bypasses government: three quarters of aid to Afghanistan is spent directly by donors without properly informing the Afghan government: this amounted to US$11bn between 2002 and 2006.
Aid is rarely evaluated: the Afghan government rarely receives information on the effectiveness of the aid programmes run by international donors.
Aid comes with strings attached: of the quarter of the annual development budget that the Afghan government is responsible for, 72% comes from international donors, with many imposing further conditions on its use.
Aid carries excessive red tape: the Afghan government’s institutional capability may be fragile, but is further undermined by excessive donor bureaucracy. Often donors employ western consultants rather than working through legitimate local and national bodies, weakening local capacity still more.
Aid comes late or not at all: Afghanistan’s flagship development programme, the National Solidarity Programme, currently has a UD$197.33 million deficit and it is estimated that it will have a funding shortfall of 87% during 2008.

Afghanistan is the world’s fourth poorest country. If it is to combat poverty and build a democratic society it will need to generate more of its own revenue and tackle institutional weaknesses. It also needs to improve its capacity to deliver services effectively – such as schools, hospitals and roads – in order to meet the requirements of its people. But current donor behavior too often works against this.

Akbar Wahdat, Afghan parliamentarian and chairperson of the Economic Literacy and Budget Analysis Group, called on the international community, donors and the government to ensure the full contribution of the people of Afghanistan in development and reconstruction of the country.

He said: “A lot of foreign money that has entered the country from external sources is used for special military and political purposes and the people of this country have had limited benefits and chances to use this money for their social and economic rehabilitation.”

The National Solidarity Programme
The report analyses aid to the National Solidarity Programme, Afghanistan’s flagship rural development programme reaching over 22,000 villages.

In a country where agriculture and related rural trades are the major sources of livelihood, the programme is supposed to lay the foundations for sustainable and inclusive local government, rural reconstruction and poverty alleviation. It currently has a US$197.33 million deficit and it is estimated that it will have a funding shortfall of 87% during 2008.

Such shortfalls lead to cases such as a school building project in Mingajik village that had to wait until 2007 to receive its second phase of funding after receiving an initial payment in 2004. Due to the lack of funds, work on the project was stopped and the school remained half built. During this time bricks were stolen, a dispute raged between the community and local authority, costs increased and the project was further delayed.

Mudasser Hussain Siddiqui, ActionAid Afghanistan policy research and advocacy coordinator acknowledged that the National Solidarity Programme has had internal administrative problems, but said that implementation failures were also due to donors not living up to funding commitments.

He said: “Donors and the international community should fulfil their commitments because every time they fail to do so it creates a downward spiral for poor communities and holds up the ongoing reconstruction of Afghanistan.

“The government, especially the Ministry of Rural Reconstruction and Development, must work with donors to avoid funding crises, and to sort out assessment procedures and ensure people’s participation.”

[ Any views expressed in this article are those of the writer and not of Reuters. ]

Email this article Send comments

Emergencies

• Afghan turmoil

MORE >>

Members

• ActionAid

MORE >>

NGO latest

• Aid to Afghanistan is in crisis, says ActionAid
ActionAid

• Poor people and war widows suffer in Afghanistan's freeze
ActionAid

• Afghanistan's bitter cold: HIA's rapid response in refugee camps
HIA - Hungary

• Freezing to death in Kabul
NRC - Norway

• ActionAid responds to the DRC earthquake
ActionAid

MORE >>

Latest news

• Car bomb hits Afghanistan's Kandahar-witnesses

• Blast hits Afghanistan's Kandahar - witnesses

• Australia to send military trainers to Afghanistan

• FACTBOX-Where do countries stand on Kosovo?

• Afghan bomb attacks to increase this year -NATO

MORE >>

[ Any views expressed in this article are those of the writer and not of Reuters. ]

Breaking stories

Car bomb hits Afghanistan's Kandahar-witnesses (1 minute ago)

Blast hits Afghanistan's Kandahar - witnesses (1 minute ago)

AlertNet insight

MEDIAWATCH: End of the road for cluster bombs? (1 minute ago)

Aid agency news feed

Aid to Afghanistan is in crisis, says ActionAid (1 minute ago)

Blogs

Bali climate change talks: 'The long, arduous road' to nowhere? (1 minute ago)

Maps

NATURAL HAZARDS: GLOBAL OVERVIEW OF COUNTRIES OF CONCERN - January 2006 (1 minute ago)

Country information

Briefings

Afghan turmoil - [Who works where]

Statistics graphs

Landmine casualties (2004)

View more stats

Del.icio.us | Digg

Digg |

NewsVine | Reddit

Latest images

Thumb for /thefacts/imagerepository/RTRPICT/2008-02-18T134609Z_01_KAR64_RTRIDSP_2_AFGHAN-TOLL_mainimage.jpg|/thenews/pictures/KAR64.htm

Thumb for /thefacts/imagerepository/RTRPICT/2008-02-18T134438Z_01_KAR65_RTRIDSP_2_AFGHAN-TOLL_mainimage.jpg|/thenews/pictures/KAR65.htm

Thumb for /thefacts/imagerepository/RTRPICT/2008-02-18T134009Z_01_KAR63_RTRIDSP_2_AFGHAN-TOLL_mainimage.jpg|/thenews/pictures/KAR63.htm

Thumb for /thefacts/imagerepository/RTRPICT/2008-02-17T110211Z_01_KAB03_RTRIDSP_2_AFGHAN-VIOLENCE_mainimage.jpg|/thenews/pictures/KAB03.htm

Thumb for /thefacts/imagerepository/RTRPICT/2008-02-17T110010Z_01_KAB04_RTRIDSP_2_AFGHAN-VIOLENCE_mainimage.jpg|/thenews/pictures/KAB04.htm

Medics in the Pakistani border town of Chaman tend to a wounded Afghan after a suicide attack in the southern Afghan town of Spin Boldak February 18, 2008. More than 20 ...

More pictures | Galleries

Last updated:Tue Feb 19 11:05:21 2008

Background

Emergencies

Members

NGO latest

Latest news

Related articles

Country information